The Science of Reading’s Next Constraint Is Coaching Capacity, Not Funding

A literacy coach walking down a school hallway carrying binders and a laptop bag, illustrating literacy coaching capacity

The share of California fourth graders reading at grade level climbed from 40% in 2014 to 46%, and districts that used state grant money for literacy coaches, reading specialists or literacy training for teachers saw scores rise about six points within two years, according to a Public Policy Institute of California study. But 42% of California districts said they had trouble hiring a literacy coach. North Carolina, further along the same implementation curve, has already rebuilt its strategy around that exact constraint: not enough people to do the coaching.

California’s Numbers Show What Coaching Investment Buys

California’s literacy overhaul dates to 2013, when the state ranked 47th nationally for fourth-grade reading on the National Assessment of Educational Progress and only 27% of students scored proficient or advanced. A decade of sequential investment followed: a 2014 English language arts framework centered on phonics and vocabulary, new curriculum materials, a dyslexia screener, and updated teacher credential requirements. The largest single investment came in 2023: $500 million in grants for schools to hire literacy coaches and take other reading-focused steps, followed by $215 million the next year and another $350 million for literacy coaches in the most recent budget.

The results are real but partial. In the most recent testing cycle, 46% of California fourth graders read at grade level, up from 40% in 2014, and the state now ranks in the middle of the pack nationally. Sarah Novicoff, a researcher at the Public Policy Institute of California, found that nearly 60% of districts used their grant money to hire literacy coaches, reading specialists, or otherwise fund literacy-focused teacher training, and that those districts saw significant improvements in reading scores, including among English learners. Where districts could staff coaching, scores moved. Where hiring fell short, the same funding bought less.

The Constraint Isn’t Funding. It’s the Labor Market.

The 42% of districts that had trouble hiring a coach didn’t skip it by choice, and the shortage is worst in rural and remote counties, where the pool of teachers qualified to coach other teachers is thin to begin with. “I’d love to hire a literacy coach,” Lassen County Office of Education superintendent Patricia Gunderson told CalMatters. “It’s great the state is offering the money, but we just can’t do it. We don’t have the capacity.”

Siskiyou County superintendent Allan Carver described a second-order version of the shortage: the coaching investment is pulling teachers into coaching roles, easing one gap while widening another. “We work to solve one issue and further exacerbate the teacher shortage,” Carver said. “We have to develop the literacy coach pipeline before we simply allocate funds and expectations for training.” The same pattern shows up in Texas’s science-of-reading implementation: funding curriculum and screeners is the easier half of the work. Building a supply of people qualified to coach teachers through it is the harder half, and it moves on a slower timeline than a budget line does.

North Carolina Already Hit This Wall, and Adjusted

North Carolina is several years ahead of California on the same curve, and its current strategy, as EdNC reported, is a direct response to the coaching-capacity constraint. The state employs just 115 Early Literacy Specialists to support literacy implementation statewide. “We only have 115 Early Literacy Specialists, which we’re grateful for, and they’re phenomenal, but North Carolina is a huge state,” said Cynthia Barber, director of the state’s Office of Early Learning. “If we’re going to scale their work, then we want to prepare the field to equip local leaders and coaches.”

That’s a deliberate shift away from specialists delivering coaching directly and toward specialists training the local instructional coaches and principals who can sustain the work after a specialist moves on. As Mary Derfel, the office’s assistant director of early literacy, put it: “We’re not just coaching instruction. We’re coaching systems that improve instruction.” State leaders describe it as a gradual release of responsibility: specialists now spend less time spread thin across many schools and more time working intensively in one or two schools per district, building local coaches who can carry the practice into every other building. The office has also opened its coaching framework to instructional coaches and principals statewide through free virtual professional learning. Coordinating that kind of embedded, teacher-facing follow-through is exactly the discipline good PLC structures are built for.

What This Means for a District’s Literacy Plan

Line up California’s data with North Carolina’s strategy and a pattern emerges. Money buys curriculum, screeners, and credential requirements. It does not, by itself, buy coaching capacity, because coaching capacity is a labor-market problem, not a procurement problem. The districts and states getting the most from their investment are the ones treating coaching capacity as its own plan, separate from the curriculum decision, whether that means building from within, as North Carolina is doing, or hiring where the labor market allows it. At Baldwin Park’s Tracy Elementary, one dedicated literacy coach helped drive a 10-point reading-score jump in two years. The open question for every other district is what to do in the buildings that don’t have one.

Where AI Coaching Fits, and Where It Doesn’t

Some uses of AI work against the science of reading. In an EdSurge piece, literacy coach Court Shuller describes an AI program that educators in his New Jersey district raved about, one that levels complex texts down to a student’s “instructional level.” When he used it with a student he tutored, the results were “lackluster.” She showed no interest, waited for him to tell her the answers, and didn’t remember the text from one session to the next. “When we keep kids from actually doing work that requires effortful thinking, they don’t learn anything at all,” Shuller wrote. AI used to remove productive struggle undercuts the research base districts have spent more than a decade funding.

AI Coach by Edthena works with teachers on their own lessons. A teacher uploads a lesson video, AI Coach analyzes the lesson and visualizes the data on a timeline, and specific feedback arrives in the teacher’s inbox in minutes. Replying keeps the coaching conversation going, and the teacher chooses how far to take it.

Even the best coach can only be in one room at a time. AI Coach adds coaching in between, for every teacher. Teachers can then bring what they’re working on to their in-person coach or PLC.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a literacy coach actually do?

Typically a former classroom teacher with additional reading-instruction training who works directly with teachers to implement science-of-reading practices: observing instruction, modeling techniques, and giving feedback a curriculum guide can’t provide alone.

How is North Carolina addressing its literacy coach shortage?

With only 115 Early Literacy Specialists statewide, the state has shifted from specialists coaching teachers directly to specialists training local instructional coaches and principals, and opened its coaching framework to leaders statewide through free virtual professional learning.

Can AI replace literacy coaches?

No. AI used to shortcut instructional rigor, such as leveling texts down instead of scaffolding students up to them, can undercut the reading gains a district is trying to build. AI Coach works alongside the coaches a district already has. Teachers can get feedback on their own lessons between coaching visits and bring what they’re working on to their coach or PLC.

What should a district’s literacy plan include beyond curriculum and reading screeners?

A plan for coaching capacity, meaning how every teacher gets coaching support. That support can come from new hires where the labor market allows them and from coaches grown within existing staff, as North Carolina is doing. AI Coach works alongside those coaches and adds coaching between visits for every teacher.

Learn more about how AI Coach works alongside the coaches your district already has.

Get new posts via email

No spam. Ever. We promise.